Andrew D. Segal | Criminal Defense Lawyer in Portland, Maine
THE LAW OFFICE OF Andrew D. Segal ATTORNEY AT LAW  •  PORTLAND, MAINE
CRIMINAL DEFENSE & LITIGATION

Fighting for Everyday People 

Prior to arriving in Maine, I practiced as an Assistant Public Defender in Cook County, Illinois, where I worked on hundreds of cases and first-chaired more than thirty trials. I now primarily represent people charged in Maine’s state and federal courts. I keep my caseload intentionally small so that I can give each case the attention, preparation, and fierce advocacy in court that my clients deserve. 

Request a complimentary consultation or email segal@adslegal.com
Andrew D. Segal, criminal defense attorney
Dedicated
TO SECURING THE BEST POSSIBLE OUTCOME
Personalized
APPROACH TO EACH AND EVERY CASE
Tenacious
ADVOCACY IN AND OUT OF COURT
Practice

What I take on

I represent people in a wide range of criminal matters, as well as civil Protection from Abuse proceedings. Here are some of the matters my practice accepts:

{{ area.title }}

{{ area.body }}

The record

Where I trained

Cook County, Illinois—home to more than five million people across Chicago and its surrounding suburbs—has one of the largest criminal court systems in the country. As an Assistant Public Defender there, I managed a felony docket of more than one hundred active cases at a time, ranging from lower-level charges to armed robbery and attempted murder. Before that, I handled roughly 350 misdemeanor cases each year. That volume taught me to master the facts quickly, identify and litigate critical issues effectively, and prepare every case to pursue the strongest possible result, including victory at trial.

IN THE COURTS

Litigating Pre-Textual Traffic Stops of Black Motorists

In one felony gun case, I drafted a motion and helped secure a ruling allowing the defense to introduce evidence that the same Chicago police officers had stopped and searched the vehicles of fourteen other Black motorists that evening despite observing no traffic violations. We argued that the officers were engaged in a “fishing expedition” for firearms. Following that ruling, the prosecution reduced the charge, which carried a six-year mandatory minimum, to a misdemeanor resolved with two days' time served. The broader pattern of pretextual traffic stops targeting Black and Latino drivers is also the subject of federal civil-rights litigation brought by the ACLU of Illinois.

{{ motionStatus }}
In the news

Exposing Illinois' Highest-Volume DUI Trooper

I helped uncover concerns about an Illinois State Police trooper who made more DUI arrests than anyone in the state, tripling his salary to nearly $250,000 of taxpayer money. As part of his scheme, he created repetitive, "cookie-cutter" reports and field sobriety results that did not match the facts. His fabrication of DUI facts resulted in the arrest and prosecution of innocent people. Our litigation contributed to a three-part nightly news series on ABC7 Chicago, about which my client, my co-counsel and I were interviewed.

Still from the ABC7 Chicago news interview
Approach

How I work

Preparation

I thoroughly investigate the facts and research the law in every case. Many cases are won through careful preparation long before a jury is ever sworn in.

Personal Attention

I will be the sole attorney handling your case. I will know the personal and legal nuances of your situation and give you candid advice grounded in a careful understanding of the facts, the law, and your needs.

Trial-Ready

I prepare every case as though it will go to trial. Even when a case ends in a negotiated resolution, prosecutors make better offers when they know the defense is prepared and willing to try the case.

About

Andrew D. Segal

I was born and raised in Cook County, Illinois, and I spent approximately five years defending people there at the Law Office of the Cook County Public Defender, first as a law clerk licensed to represent clients under supervision during law school and later as an Assistant Public Defender. I worked on hundreds of cases ranging from traffic offenses to murder trials. Most of my practice was devoted to misdemeanor and felony cases at all stages of the criminal process, from initial appearance through sentencing. I litigated a range of constitutional issues, including First Amendment questions involving the right to protest during the 2024 Democratic National Convention and Fourth Amendment challenges to police searches and seizures.

I opened this office in Maine to bring the same high-quality representation to a smaller caseload, and to serve clients at a time when the state faces a serious shortage of criminal-defense attorneys.

I believe every person deserves a robust defense and an advocate who will fight with the same urgency and care they would bring to defending a member of their own family. I am called to this work because our criminal courts do not treat everyone equally. They come down hardest on poor and working-class people, Black and brown people, those who challenge the government, and those forced to confront the criminal process without a zealous advocate.

Criminal defense cannot cure all of these systemic injustices, but it provides a vital check on the government's immense power to take away a person's freedom and forever alter the course of their life.

Everybody who is charged with a crime is entitled to due process of law and an attorney willing to fight the government on their behalf, even those who cannot afford to pay.
Why I do this work
Education
Northwestern University, J.D., cum laude
Harvard University, M.T.S.
Bates College, B.A.
Bar admissions
Maine, Illinois, and New York
Professional associations
National Lawyers Guild (NLG)
Maine Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (MACDL)
Fees and access

Who I represent

Court-appointed cases

I accept court appointments through the State of Maine to represent people who cannot afford counsel. Appointments are made by the court, not by me. I take this work by choice and provide appointed clients with the same time, attention, and commitment I bring to retained cases. A person’s right to a robust defense does not depend on their ability to pay.

Private representation

Private fees are quoted in writing based on the circumstances and expected demands of the case. Sliding-scale fees may be available based on what you can actually pay and the firm’s capacity.

Complimentary consultation

If you've been charged, get in touch.

Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential. If your matter is urgent, such as an arrest, a scheduled police interview, or a court date this week, please put "urgent" in the subject line.

Email me at segal@adslegal.com
Office
75 Pearl Street, Suite 216
Portland, ME 04101
Trial courts statewide.

Please do not describe the facts of your case here or over email. This form is only so I can gather basic information and reach you. I will treat what you send as a confidential inquiry, but I am not your lawyer until I accept the case in writing.

Something went wrong sending that. Please try again, or email segal@adslegal.com directly.